Seal of the State of Ohio. Click here to return to the Supreme Court home page. The Supreme Court of Ohio & The Ohio Judicial System. Click here to return to the Supreme Court home page. Line Drawing of the Ohio Judicial Center. Click here to return to the Supreme Court home page.
Spacer image

The Supreme Court of Ohio & The Ohio Judicial System

Clerk's Office
65 South Front Street, 8th Floor
Columbus, Ohio 43215-3431
800.826.9010
614.387.9530

Sandra H. Grosko
Clerk

Search Results: Case Number 2011-0163

The Supreme Court of Ohio

CASE INFORMATION

GENERAL INFORMATION

Case: 2011-0163 Discretionary Appeal (Non-felony)
Filed: 01/28/11
Status: Case Is Disposed
Acordia of Ohio, LLC v. Michael Fishel, Janice Freytag, Mark Taber, Sheila Diefenbach, Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC, Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc., and Joseph T. Lukens

PARTIES and ATTORNEYS

Barrett, John A. (Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
  Represented by:
    Burke, Timothy (9189) , Counsel of Record
Cintas Corporation (Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
  Represented by:
    Coletti, Robert (21798) , Counsel of Record
Hylant Group, Inc. (Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
  Represented by:
    Lafferty, Michelle (43590) , Counsel of Record
Mangan, Sean K. (Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
  Represented by:
    Burke, Timothy (9189) , Counsel of Record
Ohio Chamber of Commerce (Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
  Represented by:
    Dornette, William (2955) , Counsel of Record
Bednarczuk, Ryan (79795)
Nalbandian, John (73033)
Ohio Chemistry Technology Council (Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
  Represented by:
    Dornette, William (2955) , Counsel of Record
Bednarczuk, Ryan (79795)
Nalbandian, John (73033)
The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. (Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
  Represented by:
    Ducatman, Robert (3571) , Counsel of Record
Wilkes, Meredith (73092)
USI Holdings Corp. (Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
  Represented by:
    Cassady, Peter (5562) , Counsel of Record
USI Midwest, Inc. (Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
  Represented by:
    Cassady, Peter (5562) , Counsel of Record
Willis of Ohio, Inc. (Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
  Represented by:
    Turk, Jennifer (73781) , Counsel of Record
The Ohio Employment Lawyers' Association (Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellee)
  Represented by:
    Klingshirn, Neil (37158) , Counsel of Record
Gordillo, Gregory (63445)
Acordia of Ohio, LLC (Appellant)
  Represented by:
    McCarthy, James (2245) , Counsel of Record
Hinegardner, Laura (67576)
Diefenbach, Sheila (Appellee)
  Represented by:
    Lutz, Mark (9062) , Counsel of Record
Majba, Michael (76511)
Fishel, Michael (Appellee)
  Represented by:
    Lutz, Mark (9062) , Counsel of Record
Majba, Michael (76511)
Freytag, Janice (Appellee)
  Represented by:
    Lutz, Mark (9062) , Counsel of Record
Majba, Michael (76511)
Lukens, Joseph T. (Appellee)
  Represented by:
    Lutz, Mark (9062) , Counsel of Record
Majba, Michael (76511)
Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc. (Appellee)
  Represented by:
    Lutz, Mark (9062) , Counsel of Record
Majba, Michael (76511)
Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC (Appellee)
  Represented by:
    Lutz, Mark (9062) , Counsel of Record
Majba, Michael (76511)
Taber, Mark (Appellee)
  Represented by:
    Lutz, Mark (9062) , Counsel of Record
Majba, Michael (76511)

PRIOR JURISDICTION
Jurisdiction Information Prior Decision Date Case Number(s)
Hamilton County, 1st District Court of Appeals 12/17/2011 C100071

DOCKET ITEMS
  • Most documents that were filed in Supreme Court cases after December 1, 2006, are scanned. They are available for viewing via the online dockets, generally within one business day from their date of filing.
  • Supreme Court orders that were issued after January 1, 2007, are also available via the online docket as PDFs. Orders scanned prior to April 6, 2009, may not bear the signature of the Chief Justice. These online orders are identical to the original orders in all other respects.
  • A symbol in an online docket denotes a scanned filing or an electronic version of a Supreme Court order. Clicking the icon opens an image of the filing or order.
Date Filed Description
01/28/11 View Notice of appeal of Acordia of Ohio, Inc.
  Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
01/28/11 View Memorandum in support of jurisdiction
  Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
01/28/11 View Jurisdictional memorandum of amicus curiae The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. in support of appellant
  Filed by: The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc.
01/31/11 Copy of notice of appeal sent to clerk of court of appeals
01/31/11 View Jurisdictional memorandum of amici curiae Ohio Chamber of Commerce et al. in support of appellant
  Filed by: Ohio Chamber of Commerce
  Filed by: Ohio Chemistry Technology Council
  Filed by: USI Holdings Corp.
  Filed by: USI Midwest, Inc.
02/28/11 View Memorandum in response
  Filed by: Diefenbach, Sheila
  Filed by: Fishel, Michael
  Filed by: Freytag, Janice
  Filed by: Lukens, Joseph
  Filed by: Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc.
  Filed by: Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC
  Filed by: Taber, Mark
04/20/11 View DECISION: Appeal accepted
04/20/11 View Order to clerk of court/custodian to certify record
04/20/11 View Citation to relevant authority
  Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
04/28/11 Record
04/28/11 Clerk's notice of filing of record
06/06/11 View Stipulation to extension of time to 6/27/11 to file merit brief
  Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
06/27/11 View Appellant's merit brief
  Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
06/27/11 Supplement to brief
  Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
06/27/11 View Brief of amicus curiae Ohio Chamber of Commerce, Ohio Chemistry Technology Council, USI Holdings Corp., USI Midwest, Inc., Willis of Ohio, Inc., and Hylant Group, Inc. in support of appellant
  Filed by: Hylant Group, Inc.
  Filed by: Ohio Chamber of Commerce
  Filed by: Ohio Chemistry Technology Council
  Filed by: USI Holdings Corp.
  Filed by: USI Midwest, Inc.
  Filed by: Willis of Ohio, Inc.
06/27/11 View Brief of amicus curiae The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc. in support of appellant
  Filed by: The PNC Financial Services Group, Inc.
07/01/11 View Stipulation to extension of time to 8/16/11 to file merit brief
  Filed by: Diefenbach, Sheila
  Filed by: Fishel, Michael
  Filed by: Freytag, Janice
  Filed by: Lukens, Joseph
  Filed by: Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc.
  Filed by: Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC
  Filed by: Taber, Mark
08/15/11 View Brief of amicus curiae The Ohio Employment Lawyers' Association in support of appellees
  Filed by: The Ohio Employment Lawyers' Association
08/15/11 View Appellees' merit brief
  Filed by: Diefenbach, Sheila
  Filed by: Fishel, Michael
  Filed by: Freytag, Janice
  Filed by: Lukens, Joseph
  Filed by: Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc.
  Filed by: Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC
  Filed by: Taber, Mark
08/25/11 Oral argument scheduled for Tuesday, November 15, 2011
08/31/11 View Notice of oral argument to be held Tuesday, November 15, 2011
09/06/11 View Reply brief
  Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
09/06/11 View Reply brief of Amici Curiae Ohio Chamber of Commerce, Ohio Chemistry Technology Council, USI Holdings Corp., USI Midwest, Inc., Willis of Ohio, Inc., and Hylant Group, Inc.
  Filed by: Hylant Group, Inc.
  Filed by: Ohio Chamber of Commerce
  Filed by: Ohio Chemistry Technology Council
  Filed by: USI Holdings Corp.
  Filed by: USI Midwest, Inc.
  Filed by: Willis of Ohio, Inc.
11/15/11 Oral argument held
05/24/12 View DECISION: Affirmed. See opinion at 2012-Ohio-2297.    
06/04/12 View Motion for reconsideration
  Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
View 07/25/12: Granted; the court will be reviewing the merits of this case. The parties shall not file additional briefs.
06/04/12 View Memorandum of amici curiae Ohio Chamber of Commerce et al. in support of reconsideration
  Filed by: Cintas Corporation
  Filed by: Hylant Group, Inc.
  Filed by: Ohio Chamber of Commerce
  Filed by: Ohio Chemistry Technology Council
  Filed by: USI Holdings Corp.
  Filed by: USI Midwest, Inc.
06/04/12 View Memorandum of amici curiae Professors Sean K. Mangan and John A. Barrett Jr. in support of reconsideration
  Filed by: Barrett, John
  Filed by: Mangan, Sean
06/14/12 View Memo opposing motion for reconsideration
  Filed by: Diefenbach, Sheila
  Filed by: Fishel, Michael
  Filed by: Freytag, Janice
  Filed by: Lukens, Joseph
  Filed by: Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc.
  Filed by: Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC
  Filed by: Taber, Mark
08/17/12 View Motion for oral argument
  Filed by: Diefenbach, Sheila
  Filed by: Fishel, Michael
  Filed by: Freytag, Janice
  Filed by: Lukens, Joseph
  Filed by: Neace & Associates Insurance Agency of Ohio, Inc.
  Filed by: Neace Lukens Insurance Agency, LLC
  Filed by: Taber, Mark
View 09/05/12: Denied
08/23/12 View Memo opposing motion for oral argument
  Filed by: Acordia of Ohio, LLC
10/11/12 View DECISION: Reversed and remanded. See opinion at 2012-Ohio-4648.   
10/24/12 Return of record to clerk of court/custodian
10/26/12 Certified copy of judgment entry/mandate sent to clerk
10/31/12 Return receipt; Postage $24.40 (Box 1 of 3)
10/31/12 Return receipt; Postage $20.45 (Box 2 of 3)
11/05/12 Return receipt; Postage $23.82 (Box 3 of 3)
12/06/12 Copy of reconsideration entry sent to clerk


 


Question or Comments? ECMS Online 1.2.9